90 + Points | Critical Acclaim

90+ Points - “Critical Acclaim” by Prominent Experts. Our buyers (some of whom are chefs, but all are foodies) are our sales staff, and write their own recommendations, and most importantly, their reason(s) for offering specific wines to you, our customer |
  • These products are also recognized by the world’s most influential and prominent wine and spirits experts, including Eric Asimov (New York Times); Lettie Teague (Wall Street Journal); Jancis Robinson; James Suckling; Jeb Dunnuck; Jane Anson; Allan Meadows’ Burghound; along with the many wine writers of Decanter; Vinous, and Wine Spectator. 
  • We trust that you will enjoy these products, as they represent the many of the best wine and spirits the world has to offer.

1111 products

Benanti Etna ROSSO Sicily 2023 750ml
67Wine
Benanti Etna ROSSO Sicily 2023 750ml
90+
Nerello Mascalese | Sicily, Etna Rosso / Italy
🇮🇹 A perfumed blend of rosy florals and hints of juniper berry.
$32.99 $34.99
Save $2.00
$32.99 $34.99
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 (2)
Save $2.00
90+
🇮🇹 A perfumed blend of rosy florals and hints of juniper berry.
Benanti Terre Siciliane Nerello Cappuccio 2021 750ml
67Wine
Benanti Terre Siciliane Nerello Cappuccio 2021 750ml
90+
Nerello Cappuccio | Terre Siciliane, Sicily / France
Fairly bright ruby red with very light tints of purple. Scent is spicy, herbaceous, smoky, and mildly fruity.
$39.99
$39.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
Fairly bright ruby red with very light tints of purple. Scent is spicy, herbaceous, smoky, and mildly fruity.
Benoit Dehu Champagne Cuvee Initiation Brut Nature (Base 2021) 750ml (Introductory Price)
67Wine
Benoit Dehu Champagne Cuvee Initiation Brut Nature (Base 2021) 750ml (Introductory Price)
90+
Meunier, Pinot Noir | Champagne, France
Mineral-driven Grower Champagne with Meunier, Pinot Noir & zero dosage.
$85.23 $124.99
Save $39.76
$85.23 $124.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $39.76
90+
Mineral-driven Grower Champagne with Meunier, Pinot Noir & zero dosage.
Benoit Dehu Champagne Cuvee Initiation Rose Extra Brut (Base 2022) 750ml (Introductory Price)
67Wine
Benoit Dehu Champagne Cuvee Initiation Rose Extra Brut (Base 2022) 750ml (Introductory Price)
90+
Pinot Noir | Champagne, France
Elegant grower Rosé Champagne with cranberry, spice and vibrant minerality.
$99.85 $128.99
Save $29.14
$99.85 $128.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $29.14
90+
Elegant grower Rosé Champagne with cranberry, spice and vibrant minerality.
Benziger Family Winery Pinot Noir "Russian River Valley" Reserve 2016 750ml 67Wine
67Wine
Benziger Family Winery Pinot Noir "Russian River Valley" Reserve 2016 750ml
90+ Points | Critical Acclaim
90+Organic
The Tasting Panels awards 93 Points and writes made with certified organic grapes, utilizing...
🇺🇸 Small-production Pinot Noir — cherry, raspberry, sweet tobacco notes.
$49.99
$49.99
No reviews No reviews
90+Organic
🇺🇸 Small-production Pinot Noir — cherry, raspberry, sweet tobacco notes.
Bergstrom BERGSTROM VINEYARD Pinot Noir Biodynamic 2023 750ml 67Wine
67Wine
Bergstrom BERGSTROM VINEYARD Pinot Noir Biodynamic 2023 750ml
90+OrganicBiodynamic
Pinot Noir | Dundee Hills, Willamette Valley / Oregon
🇺🇸 deep, jeweled ruby/magenta hue and has a more introspective profile.
$149.99
$149.99
No reviews No reviews
90+OrganicBiodynamic
🇺🇸 deep, jeweled ruby/magenta hue and has a more introspective profile.
Bergstrom Cumberland Reserve Pinot Noir 2023 375ml HALF BOTTLE
67Wine
Bergstrom Cumberland Reserve Pinot Noir 2023 375ml HALF BOTTLE
90+
Half-Bottle Pinot Noir | Yamhill-Carlton, Oregon
🇺🇸 Raspberry, violet, mocha & forest floor. Willamette Valley Pinot.
$29.99
$29.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇺🇸 Raspberry, violet, mocha & forest floor. Willamette Valley Pinot.
Bergstrom CUMBERLAND Reserve Pinot Noir Willamette Valley 2024 750ml
67Wine
Bergstrom CUMBERLAND Reserve Pinot Noir Willamette Valley 2024 750ml
90+
Pinot Noir | Willamette Valley, Oregon
🇺🇸 Bright and seductive, this pinot offers fresh cherries, crushed wild berries.
$56.99
$56.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇺🇸 Bright and seductive, this pinot offers fresh cherries, crushed wild berries.
Bergstrom Silice Chehalem Mountains Pinot Noir Biodynamic 2021 750ml 67Wine
67Wine
Bergstrom Silice Chehalem Mountains Pinot Noir Biodynamic 2021 750ml
#32 Wine of the Year in the 2023 Wine Spectator Top 100
90+
Pinot Noir | Chehalem Mountains, Willamette Valley / Oregon
🇺🇸 Elegance is personified in this 2021 bottling of Bergström's renowned Silice.
$114.99 $119.99
Save $5.00
$114.99 $119.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $5.00
90+
🇺🇸 Elegance is personified in this 2021 bottling of Bergström's renowned Silice.
Beringer Vineyards  KNIGHTS VALLEY Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 750ml
67Wine
Beringer Vineyards KNIGHTS VALLEY Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 750ml
90+
Cabernet Sauvignon | Knights Valley, Sonoma County / California
🇺🇸 Bold blackcurrant, plum & cedar — Knights Valley's benchmark Cab.
$32.99 $34.99
Save $2.00
$32.99 $34.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $2.00
90+
🇺🇸 Bold blackcurrant, plum & cedar — Knights Valley's benchmark Cab.
Bertani AMARONE Della Valpolicella 2011 750ml - 67
67Wine
Bertani Amarone Della Valpolicella 2011 750ml
90+
Corvina, Rondinella | Amarone della Valpolicella, Veneto
🇮🇹 Density and dryness that really comes together here, after almost 10 years.
$149.99 $154.99
Save $5.00
$149.99 $154.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $5.00
90+
🇮🇹 Density and dryness that really comes together here, after almost 10 years.
Besserat de Bellefon Champagne Brut La Cuvee BB 1843 - 67
67Wine
Besserat de Bellefon Champagne Brut La Cuvee BB 1843
90+
Pinot Noir etc. | Champagne, France
Perfect for special occasions, this extraordinary champagne will pair perfectly with lobster or haddock.
$299.99
$299.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
Perfect for special occasions, this extraordinary champagne will pair perfectly with lobster or haddock.
Bethel Heights Estate Pinot Noir Amity-Eola Hills 2023 750ml
67Wine
Bethel Heights Estate Pinot Noir Amity-Eola Hills 2023 750ml
90+
Pinot Noir | Amity-Eola Hills, Oregon
🇺🇸 Cherry, raspberry & violet with chalky tannins. Elegant, concentrated.
$36.99 $44.99
Save $8.00
$36.99 $44.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $8.00
90+
🇺🇸 Cherry, raspberry & violet with chalky tannins. Elegant, concentrated.
Bezel Cakebread Cellars Pinot Noir San Luis Obispo Coast 2024 750ml 67Wine
67Wine
Bezel Cakebread Cellars Pinot Noir San Luis Obispo Coast 2024 750ml
90+
Pinot Noir | San Luis Obispo, California
🇺🇸 Flavors of vibrant raspberry and the subtle herbaceousness of dried oregano....
$27.99
Woman Winemaker!
$27.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇺🇸 Flavors of vibrant raspberry and the subtle herbaceousness of dried oregano....
Big Table Farm Pinot Noir WIllamette Valley 2023 750ml 67Wine
67Wine
Big Table Farm Pinot Noir Willamette Valley 2023 750ml
90+
Pinot Noir | Willamette Valley, Oregon
🇺🇸 "Supple and elegantly complex, with delicate raspberry and cherry flavors laced.
$56.99
$56.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇺🇸 "Supple and elegantly complex, with delicate raspberry and cherry flavors laced.
Billecart Salmon Champagne Brut Reserve 375ml HALF BOTTLE 67Wine
67Wine
Billecart Salmon Champagne Brut Reserve 375ml HALF BOTTLE
90+
Half-Bottle - Chardonnay & Pinot Noir | Champagne, France
🇫🇷 Satiny Champagne with Asian pear, pastry, honey, and mouthwatering acidity.
$39.99
#18 wine in VinePair's Top 50 of 2018
$39.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇫🇷 Satiny Champagne with Asian pear, pastry, honey, and mouthwatering acidity.
Billecart Salmon Champagne Le Blanc de Blancs 750ml
67wine
Billecart Salmon Champagne Le Blanc de Blancs 750ml
90+
Chardonnay | Champagne, France
Pure Grand Cru Chardonnay—creamy, chalky and beautifully refined.
$108.99 $114.99
Save $6.00
$108.99 $114.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $6.00
90+
Pure Grand Cru Chardonnay—creamy, chalky and beautifully refined.
Billecart Salmon Le Rose Brut Champagne 750ml
67Wine
Billecart Salmon Le Rose Brut Champagne 750ml
90+
Primary Varietal - Chardonnay | Champagne / France
🇫🇷 Pliant, creamy and super-expressive, this edition is striking.
$99.99 $124.99
Save $25.00
$99.99 $124.99
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 (1)
Save $25.00
90+
🇫🇷 Pliant, creamy and super-expressive, this edition is striking.
Billecart Salmon ROSE Brut NV Champagne 1.5L MAGNUM
67Wine
Billecart Salmon ROSE Brut NV Champagne 1.5L MAGNUM
90+
Pinot noir etc. | Champagne, France
An subtle nose with plenty of fine autolysis aromas of fresh bread and sweetly fragrant yeasty notes.
$209.99
Multiple 90+ Points Awards
$209.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
An subtle nose with plenty of fine autolysis aromas of fresh bread and sweetly fragrant yeasty notes.
Billecart-Salmon Champagne Brut  Le Reserve 750ml
67Wine
Billecart-Salmon Champagne Brut Le Reserve 750ml
#18 Wine in VinePair's Top 50
90+
Primary Varietal - Meunier | Champagne, France
🇫🇷 Reflections of straw yellow, fine slowly rising bubbles and persistent mousse.
$74.99
$74.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇫🇷 Reflections of straw yellow, fine slowly rising bubbles and persistent mousse.
Biondi Santi Brunello di Montalcino Tenuta Greppo Riserva 2015 750ml - 67
67Wine
Biondi Santi Brunello di Montalcino Tenuta Greppo Riserva 2015 750ml
90+
Sangiovese Grosso | Tuscany, It.
A powerful, medium-to full-bodied Brunello, but seamless and bright.
$679.99
$679.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
A powerful, medium-to full-bodied Brunello, but seamless and bright.
Birichino Zinfandel Old Vines Gimelli Vineyard 2023 750ml
67Wine
Birichino Zinfandel Old Vines Gimelli Vineyard 2023 750ml
90+
Zinfandel | Cienega Valley / California
🇺🇸 a big fruit bomb of a Zinfandel from very old vines...
$36.99
$36.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇺🇸 a big fruit bomb of a Zinfandel from very old vines...
Blue Rock Baby Blue Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 750ml - 67
67Wine
Blue Rock Baby Blue Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 750ml
90+
Cabernet Sauvignon | Sonoma County / California
A supple, deeply fruity wine that’s generous in blueberry, milk chocolate and black cherry flavors on a full body.
$32.00
Warehouse Stored
$32.00
No reviews No reviews
Warehouse Stored
90+
A supple, deeply fruity wine that’s generous in blueberry, milk chocolate and black cherry flavors on a full body.
Bodega Colome Estate Torrontes Valle Calchaqui 2025 750ML
67Wine
Bodega Colome Estate Torrontes Valle Calchaqui 2025 750ML
90+ScrewTop
Torrontés | Valle Calchaquí, Salta / Argentina
🇦🇷 High-altitude Torrontés · Salta · Tuberose, lime & grapefruit · V:91 Best Buy
$13.99 $15.99
Save $2.00
$13.99 $15.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $2.00
90+ScrewTop
🇦🇷 High-altitude Torrontés · Salta · Tuberose, lime & grapefruit · V:91 Best Buy
Bodega Vivaltus Vivaltus Ribera del Duero 2018 750ml 67Wine
67Wine
Bodega Vivaltus Vivaltus Ribera del Duero 2018 750ml
RP 95pts, Tim Atkins 98pts
90+
Tempranillo | Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Leon / Spain
🇪🇸 Muscular, slate hewn tannins, this has a rugged quality....
$199.99
$199.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇪🇸 Muscular, slate hewn tannins, this has a rugged quality....
Bodegas Alto Moncayo Campo de Borja Grenache Locos Por El Vino Zismero 2023 750ml - 67
67Wine
Bodegas Alto Moncayo Campo de Borja Grenache Locos Por El Vino Zismero 2023 750ml
90+
Grenache | Campo de Borja, Campo, Aragon / Spain
A pleasant freshness with a successful combination of red fruits such as cherries and currants; the short aging in wood rounds off the palate.
$19.99
$19.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
A pleasant freshness with a successful combination of red fruits such as cherries and currants; the short aging in wood rounds off the palate.
Bodegas Arzuaga Navarro Ribera Del Duero Reserva 2021 750ml
67Wine
Bodegas Arzuaga Navarro Ribera Del Duero Reserva 2021 750ml
90+
Primary Varietal Tempranillo | Ribera del Duero, Castilla Y Leon / Spain
Spicy oak to the fresh blackberries with some vanilla, smoke, walnut and dried orange peel.
$59.99
$59.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
Spicy oak to the fresh blackberries with some vanilla, smoke, walnut and dried orange peel.
Bodegas Beronia Rioja GRAN Reserva 2018 750ml 67Wine
67Wine
Bodegas Beronia Rioja GRAN Reserva 2018 750ml
90+
Tempranillo etc. | Rioja / Spain
🇪🇸 Staff Pick Oscar..one of my favorite Gran Reservas.
$45.99
$45.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇪🇸 Staff Pick Oscar..one of my favorite Gran Reservas.
Bodegas Caro Aruma Malbec Mendoza 2023 750ml
67Wine
Bodegas Caro Aruma Malbec Mendoza 2023 750ml
90+
Malbec | Mendoza / Argentina
🇦🇷 Rothschild x Catena Malbec: violet, plum & fresh herbs.
$16.99 $18.99
Save $2.00
$16.99 $18.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $2.00
90+
🇦🇷 Rothschild x Catena Malbec: violet, plum & fresh herbs.
Bodegas El Nido CLIO Jumilla 2023 750ml 67Wine
67Wine
Bodegas El Nido CLIO Jumilla 2023 750ml
Wine Spectator Top 100 Wines #56 2022 Vintage
90+
Monastrell and Cabernet Sauvignon | Jumilla, Murcia / Spain
The palate is creamy, flavorful and delicate in tannins.
$65.99
Out of Stock
$65.99
No reviews No reviews
Out of Stock
90+
The palate is creamy, flavorful and delicate in tannins.
Bodegas Escudero Serna Imperial Reserva Rioja 2015 750ml
67Wine
Bodegas Escudero Serna Imperial Reserva Rioja 2015 750ml
90+
Tempranillo | Rioja Baja, Rioja / Spain
🇪🇸 95-pt Rioja Reserva: red fruit, spice, tobacco & leather, supple and rounded.
$23.99 $25.99
Save $2.00
$23.99 $25.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $2.00
90+
🇪🇸 95-pt Rioja Reserva: red fruit, spice, tobacco & leather, supple and rounded.
Bodegas Martinez Lacuesta Hinia Rioja Reserva 2014 750ml
67Wine
Bodegas Martinez Lacuesta Hinia Rioja Reserva 2014 750ml
90+
Tempranillo | Rioja Alavesa, Spain
🇪🇸 Spiced and ripe plums and cherries gain the energy of citrus zest.
$32.99
Staff Pick
$32.99
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 (2)
Staff Pick
90+
🇪🇸 Spiced and ripe plums and cherries gain the energy of citrus zest.
Bodegas Martinez Lacuesta Rioja Gran Reserva 2011 750ml
67Wine
Bodegas Martinez Lacuesta Rioja Gran Reserva 2011 750ml
90+
Tempranillo | Haro, Rioja / Spain
🇪🇸 #43 Wine Enthusiast Top 100 of 2018
$42.99 $44.99
Save $2.00 Staff Pick
$42.99 $44.99
No reviews No reviews
Save $2.00 Staff Pick
90+
🇪🇸 #43 Wine Enthusiast Top 100 of 2018
Bodegas Montecillo 22 Barricas Grand Reserva 2011 750ml - 67
67Wine
Bodegas Montecillo 22 Barricas Grand Reserva 2011 750ml
90+
Tempranillo | Rioja, Spain
The vines are an average of morethan 35 years old and low yields.
$164.99
$164.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
The vines are an average of morethan 35 years old and low yields.
Bodegas Muga Rioja Reserva Unfiltered 2022 375ml HALF BOTTLE
67Wine
Bodegas Muga Rioja Reserva Unfiltered 2022 375ml HALF BOTTLE
90+
Half-Bottle Tempranillo etc. | Rioja, Spain
🇪🇸 Cedar, red fruit & silky tannins. Classic Rioja Reserva in a half bottle.
$19.99
#51 Wine Spectator Top 100 of 2024
$19.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇪🇸 Cedar, red fruit & silky tannins. Classic Rioja Reserva in a half bottle.
Bodegas Olarra Cerro Anon Reserva Rioja 2020 750ml
67Wine
Bodegas Olarra Cerro Anon Reserva Rioja 2020 750ml
90+
Tempranillo, Graciano, Mazuelo | Rioja Alta, Rioja / Spain
🇪🇸 Staff Pick Oscar — approachability to drink now, and the hutzpah to hold years
$18.99
$18.99
No reviews No reviews
90+
🇪🇸 Staff Pick Oscar — approachability to drink now, and the hutzpah to hold years